John Garth blogs about the Middle-earth centenary — link >>>
Read more about the world’s tallest tree here — link >>>
Beleriand’s vast forests would certainly be apt homes for these giants.
The second and final part of my description of Umbar in the early Fourth Age.
Current Sources of Unrest
Umbar is a unruly place and the city’s rulers do not have effective control of the alleys and quays. Here is a list of a few internal troubles that the game master may use to build a noir campaign.
The conflicts between the Darazai and the Westron inhabitants have not declined in bitterness. The Westrons know that that if Gondor’s rule falters, they may become victims of new pogroms. Therefore they have become loyal supporters of King Elessar. The Traditionalists, too, have been forced to accept Elessar. The few remaining Black Númenoreans play along and once again pretend to be Traditionalists to avert undesirable attention.
Most Darazai think that the previous regime was a despicable fraud that pushed the city into Sauron’s sphere of influence and thereby caused a disaster. After all, more than half of the Corsairs that died at Pelargir in the War of the Ring belonged to this ethnicity. So all rumors – and they are far too common – about Black Númenorean activities may cause violent riots. But many Darazai also hate Elessar, because they see him as a foreigner who subjugated Umbar after a humiliating defeat. They wish to regain independence, when they will be able to reestablish the slave trading and piracy that earlier provided them with gold and cheap labor.
The Knife Dancers are a conspiracy of militant Darazai who strive to make the situation in Umbar so untenable that Gondor gives in and abandons the city. They work clandestinely to kill or maim those that they consider to be snitches and traitors. Westron people suffer particularly badly, but also newly arrived Gondorean administrators and merchants have been targets to ever more sophisticated attacks: stabbings, arson, collapsing buildings and other violent crimes, frequently with innocent victims, too. The City Watch’s harsh countermeasures fuel resentment among the Darzai who see their homes ransacked and their sons being dragged away to the citadel for interrogation.
Tiwwir, a Darazai prince who rules a country just to the east of Umbar, is an opportunist. When Sauron had fallen, his army intervened in Umbar. He wanted to establish order and find ways of profiting from the new order. When Elessar made clear that Gondor was about to annex Umbar, Tiwwir backed down and made a pact with the new King. But he keeps on looking for ways of earning money and gaining political influence. His agents move in all strata in Umbar and that is not appreciated by Umbar’s merchants, who disapprove of a man they see as an uncouth rustic.
A rumor has been spreading through Umbar during the last few months. A nameless prophetess moves in the alleys, somebody who neither the City Watch nor the Knife Dancers are able to find, but who is generously received by poor people. She preaches that a moon child is about to be born, a renewer who will establish more fair Umbar, who will make peace between the Darazai and the Westrons and who will put an end to violent strife in the city. Then the commoners will fear neither the servants of the fallen Eye nor the swords of Gondor. Instead, Umbar will once more be the master of her own fate.
Who is the prophetess and what is her true goal? These questions trouble the governor, the secret master of the Knife Dancers, and many crime lords. Is her message a threat or an opportunity? Is some other power behind her? Is she the emissary of a new Shadow? Only the game master knows the truth and while arrange developments to ensure an exciting campaign.
Campaign 1: The Watchmen
Umbar has a new City Watch. The old one was dissolved by Gondor’s governor, who instead gave Pelargirean officers orders to establish a new and more honest force. Finding recruits was easy, but they were only slightly less corrupt than the old constables. This campaign seed is based on the player characters getting assigned to the same unit the City Watch, charged with investigating serious crimes. See it as TV series The Wire in Middle-earth: low-tech law enforcement in shabby port districts or in sumptuous palaces. The unit’s members have a varied background, because it must contains all types of skills.
Umbar is a cynical place. Few people like the new regime and its ambitions concerning law and order, though many are relieved that the black clergy of the Storm Lord have vanished. The watchmen will have a hard time at work: acquiring contacts and snitches in the alleys is difficult but necessary for solving crimes.
And one day, a scary question come from the Watch Commander: “And how should we handle the rumors that a new Shadow have arrived in Umbar?”
Campaign 2: The Umbrai
The player characters form an Umbrai gang that earn their living through petty crime while trying to set the big heist that will get them plenty of gold. The City Watch is the enemy and the Darazai compatriots are deceitful. The only ones you trust are your own – or maybe not even them?
The player characters have to stake out a territory in the port district, and to get money through theft, smuggling or protection. At the same time, they have to pay tribute to a boss, one of the city’s wealthy merchants. He gives lucrative jobs to loyal henchmen and punishes disloyal ones. Umbrai life is like dancing of a knife edge – get the wrong enemy and you’ll end up floating among the anchored ships.
And one day, the boss asks: “And how should we handle the rumors that a new Shadow have arrived in Umbar? How can we benefit from that?”
Campaign 3: The Shadow
Mordor has fallen. Sauron and his Nazgul have perished. But many servants of the Eye survived because they were not in Mordor on that particular day. Umbar, a festering lesion in King Elessar’s realm, now attracts some of these sorcerers, undead, and wraiths. Here are still fragments of the Shadow’s powers imbued in the soil, remnants from the long centuries during which Sauron’s servants used arcane arts to influence winds and weather and carried out gruesome sacrifices in temples that nowadays have been razed. The Dúnedain remain the enemy. Their Eldar allies have departed from Middle-earth, so now there will be a new opportunity to sow the seeds of the Shadow among weak men. The goal is to harm the Dúnedain in the long run – but do undead ever feel hurried?
This arrangement suits a small player group, perhaps to or three gamers. The player characters are powerful deathless, for instance sorcerers or undead that resemble men well enough to be able to walk the streets of Umbar without getting identified. The dark magic has grown weaker and now it mainly deals with ways of influencing minds, to deceive and create distrust. The goal is to let the Shadow be recreated in a new guise, one that is not associated with Sauron. A campaign may cover many decades of Gondor’s history, with years between the scenarios.
This is my version of Umbar. JRR Tolkien never described the city in great detail and therefore I here portray her as she ought to be in my opinion. You may call this noir approach “Ardapunk”, i.e. a touch of William Gibson added to Middle-earth. The outline is system-free; I recommend System D6 Fantasy or True20 as they are flexible rules engines.
When someone from Gondor envisions Umbar, she will think of a den of vice, winding dirty alleys, haggling bazaar merchants, languid aristocrats reclining on divans being waited upon by half-naked female slaves. All of it basking in tropical heat illuminated by a bright sun in a clear sky. However, these notions are just parts of the Umbar — there is so much more one can learn by going there.
In Umbar an adventurer may uncover ruins, documents and objects dating back to before Númenor’s fall. The city changed hands five or six times during the Third Age, mostly following major battles or sieges. The past is extensive and it influence the present in many ways. (Grim Indiana Jones-style developments in Middle-earth – why not?)
Umbar’s most distinctive feature is the lively port where products from the Harad hinterlands are loaded on ships destined for realms to the far south. Her sailors are skillful, her pirates brave and her merchants sharp. All port cities are fertile ground for shady business among alleys and magazines. Goods, services and gold change hands, frequently in ways that contravene both the law and Gondorean sensibilities.
When Sauron openly proclaimed himself Lord of Mordor in TA 2951 (in a campaign context, about 75 years ago), his Umbarean supporters rebelled against the rulers of the city. An alliance of Black Númenorean clerics in the Temple of the Storm Lord and Southron magnates seized power. During one blood-soaked week, their henchmen killed everyone deemed to pose a threat against the new order. After the revolt, a duumvirate, consisting of the High Priest of the Storm Lord and the principal corsair chieftain, ruled Umbar. Barad-dûr quickly dispatched an ambassador who was charged with ensuring Umbar’s compliance with Mordor’s strategic plans.
When the news of Sauron’s demise reached Umbar, it ignited a popular revolt. Several thousand people that had – or were suspected of having – served Mordor were killed in the streets and their properties were looted and torched. The Storm priests were slain in their temple. In a few days, about half of the Umbareans with Gondorean or Númenorean ancestry perished. Many survived only because kind-hearted Southrons hid them from the rampaging mobs.
When the violence threatened to spill over into adjacent lands, the Harad prince Tiwwir dispatched troops to the city to restore a semblance of order. A chaotic time followed until Gondor’s navy, consisting of captured Corsair ships, arrived. The White Tree banner was raised above Umbar’s citadel and governor Targon, son of Tuor, proclaimed King Elessar’s decision to annex the city, together with the depopulated Harondor, to Gondor.
That happened seven years ago. Targon’s power is still fragile. Most inhabitants accept his rule, because there is no credible alternative, but too few like it and too many hate it.
If the players are to feel that this is a Middle-earth campaign and not a case of vanilla fantasy, one of Tolkien’s fundamental concepts must permeate the milieu: the struggle between Dúnedain’s ideals and the Shadow.
The wise know that Melkor infused his Shadow in Arda’s essence during the First Age and it can never be fully expunged. The Shadow, regardless of what creature serves as its foremost agent, is always selfish, false and cruel. It deceives and corrupts, and any Man who serves it will get his soul marred.
On the other hand, Dúnedain’s ideals emphasize courage, mercy, generosity and fairness. That difference must be an essential part of the campaign’s moral structure.
During the Third Age, Middle-earth was home to several powerful magicians, such as Elrond, Galadriel, Gandalf and the nine Nazgul, but now they are all gone. Those spell-casters that remain are much weaker (except perhaps Radagast). They are mainly servants of the Shadows that escaped Sauron’s downfall by not being in Mordor on the fateful day.
Also, many enchanted objects, wrought in the past by light and dark powers, remain: blades from Westernesse, Elven artifacts, talismans from the Lands of Shadows, and so on.
Minas Tirith is 3,000 years old
Umbar is 4,500 years old
Minas Tirith has a Mediterranean climate
Umbar has a tropical climate
Minas Tirith is built according to a strict plan
Umbar is an urban maze
Minas Tirith has grey and white buildings
Umbar has terracotta and khaki building
Minas Tirith has an honest administration
Umbar has a corrupt administration
Minas Tirith is an administrative and military center
Umbar is a mercantile center
Minas Tirith is characterized by social stability
Umbar is characterized by social instability
Umbar’s climate is quite different from Anórien’s: two seasons instead of four.
The rainy season occurs during the two months after the summer solstice. Heavy rains pour down every afternoon and evening, while the morning usually are sunny. The dry season occupies the rest of the year.
The hot and arid six weeks before the rainy season are the harshest. The heat is oppressive and water is getting short. People stay indoors during daytime and work in lantern light during evenings and nights. When the rains arrive, they are celebrated by popular festivals.
The four weeks after the winter solstice are cool. Then the inhabitants have to cover themselves with cloaks and use blankets when sleeping.
For thousands of years people from near and distant lands have migrated to the teeming Umbar: many kinds of Southrons from the Harad hinterland, Westrons (i.e. common Gondoreans), and black-skinned people from the lands further south. All have brought their languages, but the two vernaculars used in the bazaars and the city chancelleries are a distinctive dialect of Westron and the Haradaic language Daraz.
At the beginning of the Fourth Age, Umbar has about 40,000 inhabitants, of which one half belongs to the Southron people Darazai. They have lived in the rural region around Umbar since before the arrival of the Númenoreans. There they cultivate rice and sweet potato and breed pigs and buffaloes. Many also earn their living as fishermen in the vast Bay of Umbar.
Dúnedain migrated to Umbar at many occasions in the past. The first group arrived during the Second Age and they became loyal member of the King’s Men, the faction that supported the defiance of the Valar. These so called Black Númenoreans fell under Sauron’s domination and became worshipers of Melkor. When their regime was subjugated by Gondor around TA 800, they went into hiding. When Sauron clandestinely reemerged in Middle-earth around TA 1000, his emissaries came to Umbar to ensure that the faction would survive.
For two thousand years, the Black Númenoreans have lived here in the guise of a small number of closely knit Dúnedain families, always pretending to be loyal to current rulers of the city. After the Kin-strife, they professed fidelity to the supporters of Castamir. Whenever appropriate, they restored their dark cult, always in a new disguise so that it will not be directly associated with Sauron. During the third millennium of the Third Age, they therefore erected the Temple of the Storm Lord, the sanctuary of a harsh wind god.
After the Kin-strife, Umbar became the power base for the Traditionalists, Castamir’s defeated faction. They formed a new distinct Dúnedain group who considered themselves to be Gondor’s true masters and who promoted a strict doctrine of ethnic superiority. Therefore they only intermarried among their own. But they never adopted the Melkorian ideals of the Black Númenoreans.
The Traditionalists lost power when Gondor conquered Umbar in TA 1810. When the city regained independence two centuries later, they could not return to power. Instead they had to accept the rule of Southron magnates. The Traditionalist families, however, kept their position in the ship-building business thanks to old and scrupulously guarded trade secrets. The Traditionalists speak archaic Adunaic among themselves, while using the vernacular with outsiders.
Most of the Umbareans of Gondorean origins are not Dúnedain. They instead belong to the people that lived in the lower Anduin valley long before the arrival of Elendil. During Gondor’s golden age TA 800-1400, they settled in all corners of the empire. For two thousand years, one third of Umbar’s population belonged to this ethnic group, usually called the Westrons, but after the massacres at the end of the Third Age their ratio fell to one fifth.
During the last centuries of the Third Age, much of Gondor’s scum fled to Umbar to escape the law: fraudsters, thieves and opportunists. These individuals intermingled with the Southron, thereby creating the Umbrai ethnicity: a detested gondo-umbarean urban proletariat, that currently comprises one tenth of the population. These individuals mostly look like the Westrons, dress like the Darazai, and speak a distinct Westron jargon with a heavy influence from Daraz. They mainly work in the shipyards, on the quays and in inns and guesthouses. Their subculture is rough and unscrupulous.
Before governor Targon’s arrival, household slaves comprised one tenth of the population. Their homelands were mainly coastal regions further south, where they had been captured by local slave takers and sold to Umbarean traders who brought them to the city’s slave auctions. Some were bought by rich men from the Harad hinterlands, but most ended up in Umbarean homes. There they were assigned simple or unpleasant chores. Males often handled latrines and the removal of animal cadavers, whereas most females became household drudges.
One of the first decrees issued by King Elessar’s governor abolished slavery. However, the liberated individuals have rarely been able to leave Umbar for their old homelands. Instead they remain a distinct group in the city, frequently in their old occupations where they now earn small wages for their toils. People know who they are and usually discriminate against them – the common prejudice claims that the ex-slaves are stupid and must be managed with a firm hand.
Khunti is a tribe from the lands east of Umbar. They mainly live as nomads herding cattle on the steppes. Around the autumn equinox, they take their herds to Umbar and make good business with the abattoirs located outside the city walls, where the meat is cured, dried or turned into sausage. Some Khunti have settled in Umbar and work as butchers. They speak Khûn, a distant relative to Daraz. The Khunti have little respect for the Darazai, whom the consider to be weaklings. On the other hand, most Darazai see the Khunti as arrogant barbarians and gladly joke about touchy nomads who embarrass themselves among sophisticated townsmen.
From the coasts to the far south come the tall Arboraku people. They are skilled fishermen and sailors and therefore many of them earn their living on Umbar’s merchantmen or in the fish markets. Their language is Twuru.
Part II of Umbar Noir will contain campaign seeds outlining ways of running gritty scenarios in the city.
“When you think of the great Battle of the Pelennor, do not forget the battles in Dale and the valour of Durin’s Folk. Think of what might have been. Dragon-fire and savage swords in Eriador! There might be no Queen in Gondor.”
Running the Dwarf Campaign
King Dain of Erebor expects war and wants to know what coming his way. Therefore, the goal of the Dwarven player characters (i.e. the king’s emissaries) is to uncover what threats are brewing in Rhûn. The Dwarves distrust Men and Elves and they are prideful and stubborn. However, the dire times will force them to cooperate with people that they detest.
One recurring development in the campaign is that the player characters end up in uncomfortable places. Dwarves are at home in the mountains, but here they must travel on river boats, walk through dark forests and visit “decadent” Easterling towns. Role-playing these hardships is supposed to be a challenge to the players.
What Will the King’s Emissaries Do?
The campaign should start after the first visit of Sauron’s messenger to king Dain. The king is worried and wants to know what is going on in the east. Rewriting the general passage of events in the War of the Ring is not really possible, so the Dwarven player characters’ prime task is to ascertain what forces the Shadow is about to muster in Rhûn and find then ways of weakening those foes, e.g. by sowing dissension and doubt. (They can for instance try to make one or two Easterling warlords abstain from joining the invading army.) But the task is not easy: Dwarves are disliked in many places and Rhûnian nobles are often as insolent and brave as Durin’s folk, though more cynical and prone to break their words.
Radagast the Brown
Radagast the wizard makes only one appearance in The Lord of the Rings, i.e. when he delivers Saruman’s message to Gandalf on June 29, 3018. When Elrond’s scouts visit Radagast’s abode Rhosgobel near the Mirkwood in the late autumn that year, it is empty. The wizard’s whereabouts during the War of the Ring are never revealed and that void is used in this campaign outline.
It appears unlikely that one of the powerful mages among the Free Peoples would stand aside when the future of the world is at stake. Gandalf is active on the southern front of the war, so it seems plausible that Radagast would head for the northern front in order to assist Men, Elves and Dwarves. He is an earth mage, unlike Gandalf (fire), Elrond (water), and Galadriel (air), with a particular affinity for animals and birds. (And he should not resemble the hippie character in Peter Jackson’s movies. The Istari are majestic fellows.)
Radagast serves as a powerful NPC ally whose task is to advise, suggest and warn. However, he will not assume leadership. The rulers among Free Peoples are free to determine their own courses of action and do the hard work. Aspiring for political power is dangerous for a wizard – see what Saruman’s ambitions did to him.
Politics around the Inland Sea in 3018
Sauron wants to mobilize the Easterlings around the Inland Sea for a large-scale campaign against the Free Peoples in early 3019. But methods suitable for ruling Orcs will not work here. Instead Sauron has to use bait and stick to get the many chieftains and princes of Rhûn to join his cause and he needs to override the mistrust or dislike these men have for one another. The Easterlings have little sympathy for the ideals of the Dúnedain. Instead they are mainly motivated by self-interest, cynicism and opportunism.
Here are three of the issues that both Sauron’s and Dain’s emissaries must deal with:
• The merchant aristocrats in Tvorchoz are mainly interested in keeping trade going and maintain favorable treaties they have forced on weaker chieftains around the Inland Sea.
• Shuram, the Rodid prince who currently rules Dorwinion, earns a lot of silver by selling wine to the Forest Elves, Dale and Erebor. Therefore he and the vineyard owners in his realm are quite unhappy with the prospects of war.
• Orish is a charismatic warlord who dominates several coastal towns. He looks forward to war, glory and plunder in faraway lands. (For instance, use the Viking chieftain Harald Hardrada as a template.) Sauron sees Orish as the right man to command the campaign against Erebor, but Dorwinion stands in the way in the lower Celduin valley. However, breaking Shuram by military means would be so costly that it could seriously weaken the host heading for Rhovanion.
Morlug: Sauron’s Hand in Northern Rhûn
During the Second Age, Celebrimbor wrought more rings than the Three, the Nine and the Seven. They are known as lesser Rings but they are still powerful. Many were seized by Sauron during the conquest of Eregion almost five millennia ago [sources: Gandalf’s history lecture to Frodo in the Shire; the description of the sack of Eregion in Unfinished Tales part two, ch. IV: Concerning Galadriel and Celeborn].
Sauron has dispatched the ring-wight Morlug to northern Rhûn to handle the political complications. He will use the Cult of the Red Star, Orish the warlord, gold, sorcery and drugs to ensure that the military campaign starts on schedule in early 3019.
Morlug was a Black Númenorean nobleman who joined Sauron during the Second Age and therefore received a lesser ring as a reward. He has retained his corporeal shape, even though he is undead. His heart does not beat and he breathes only when he needs to speak in a thin and sharp voice or when he wants to smell something. Thanks to his ring, his senses are far more acute than any man’s: his sight is not hindered by darkness or fog, and he has a dog’s sense of smell, a cat’s hearing and a bear’s strength. Daylight causes no problem to him. He is also able to radiate despair and fear at will, though not as strongly as a Nazgûl. However, he will shirk away from Elves and items imbued with Elvish virtue. And he will not be able to stand up against Radagast in a confrontation, if the Wizard chooses to manifest his full power.
The Easterlings’ Invasion in 3019
The Easterlings will attack Dale and Erebor by boat. Five thousand men in 500 boats sail and row up the Celduin to Long Lake, where they pillage Laketown and land near Dale. King Brand and king Dain mobilize 2000 men and 200 Dwarves in response. That army is defeated on March 15-17 while trying to hold Dale. Half of the army is lost, together with the two kings. Meanwhile, the local civilians have sought refuge inside the Lonely Mountain, where they are defended by the remnants of the allied host.
Ten days of siege ensue before the news of Sauron’s demise reach Rhovanion. On March 27, the Easterlings lose their will to fight and retreat down the Celduin. Morlug disappears quietly at the same time and nobody seems to know what happened to him. His ring has lost its power, but he may still be able to “survive” on his own, though considerably weaker in might and magic.
The War’s Aftermath
“Don’t adventures ever have an end? I suppose not. Someone else always has to carry on the story.”
By the end of March, the war in the north is over. However, Rhûn will suffer from political turmoil for years as the balance of power shifts between the local strongmen. Gondor is not strong enough to impose its will in that area, so Rhovanion’s Dwarves and Free Men face plenty of new problems. Hence, the campaign may go on and deal with economic reconstruction and political realignment. Dale and Laketown need to be rebuilt once more and river trade must resume before the onset of winter to avoid famine in the pillaged areas.
And who knows what a vengeful Morlug might be up, hidden in a stronghold somewhere along the coast of the Inland Sea?